13 September 2010
Why I am Against The Ground Zero Mosque
Part 2 - Freedom
Note: Part 1 - Tolerance is here

"Who Did That?"
(art by Angus MacDonnall)
|
Freedom
"Why doesn't God just make us love him?" Because forced love is not love at all. One must be free to choose to love or hate, ignore or worship, believe or not, follow or stray.
The men and women who built this country understood freedom because they understood history. And they were living under a system that was becoming far less free. The Declaration of Independence not only states how important freedom is, but states that it is obvious (self-evident) and that it is provided by God:
|
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
|
Freedom doesn't guarantee that happiness, but it does guarantee the liberty, the freedom to pursue it. The Declaration again:
|
That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.
|
We are guaranteed the right to freedom of religion and freedom of speech. The Bill of Rights acknowledges what the government can not take away: this includes your Bible or your Koran, your M16 or your AK-47 (although, you can't have auto versions of those, courtesy of the National Firearms Act of 1934). This doesn't mean that the government doesn't attempt to take away or restrict these freedoms (did I mention the National Firearms Act of 1934?), it's just that ideally -- Constitutionally -- it isn't supposed to and that any restrictions must be with the "consent of the governed."
Does pastor Terry Jones have a right to burn a Koran (or a flag or a draft card or a bra)? He certainly does. Will burning a Koran incite Muslims to violence? Frankly, no. Oh, Muslims can "use it as an excuse," but it's just one of many excuses, some of which include land, clothing, diet, speech, aka "freedom."
Muslims have been doing violence against other Muslims, Jews, Christians, atheists, animists, and you-name-it-ists centuries before Terry Jones, before 9/11, before Columbus. It's what they do. I'm not talking about the occasional nut job who uses religion to do something dangerous, violent, or stupid. I'm talking about the very foundation of Islam. One toasted Koran, more or less, isn't going to finally make Muslims violent. They crossed that bridge long ago and mostly because Islam is not about freedom.
 
If Terry Jones is free do burn a Koran, should he? No. It's childish. It draws attention to Terry Jones, not to the Mosque, and not to Christ; and it is not loving (or even "tough loving"). It is not what Christians do. Now, if Terry Jones said, "I'm going to go to Ground Zero and pray every day about this and invite Christians from everywhere to do the same," I'd be all for it.
How about building something? Can't I build whatever I want wherever I want? No and there are a host of reasons why. You cannot build something on someone else's property, of course. You also can't build something on your property that you're not zoned for or that would violate your neighbors ability to enjoy their properties or that would be dangerous. Sounds reasonable and it is.
Thus, you can't build a strip joint right next to a school. It would be a stupid place to build it anyway, and yes, "stupid" is something to consider. Or, to be more gentle, replace "stupid" with "unwise." Pornographic billboards? Abercrombie & Fitch might think it's cool, but porn for marketing is so 1990s, and they wouldn't fly in my neighborhood (and I live in Los Angeles).
What of those individuals who want to build a 15-story Mosque at Ground Zero in Manhattan, site where some 3,000 people were slaughtered in the name of Allah? Do they have the same right to be unwise that Terry Jones has? Feisal Abdul Rauf (occupation: Imam) maintains that by building a mosque at Ground Zero -- scheduled to open on the 10-year anniversary of the 9/11 attack -- he and his backers are "promoting integration, tolerance of difference and community cohesion through arts and culture" and that the Mosque "will provide a place where individuals, regardless of their backgrounds, will find a center of learning, art, and culture; and most importantly, a center guided by Islamic values in their truest form -- compassion, generosity, and respect for all."
I wonder if all Muslims got Rauf's memo:
|
On 'Unbelievers," i.e. Non-Muslims (Dr. Main Khalid Al-Qudah 22 July 2007)
"Our belief is that Islam is the final divine religion, supersedes all other divine religions, and that all other religions are abrogated by the prophet hood of Mohammad PBUH. In another words; no one has the right to stay on his/her Christianity or Judaism after the prophecy of Mohammad PBUH. Based on the above, if any one from the people of scriptures has received the message of Islam clearly, yet, insisted on his belief, then he is -- from an Islamic perspective -- a disbeliever. Our doctrine is that paradise is granted for all original Muslims, and for those who embraced Islam after acknowledging the prophecy of Mohammad PBUH. Meanwhile, we believe that hellfire is granted for the disbelievers, which include anyone did not believe in the prophethood of the messenger that he/she lived during his/her life. This includes anyone that received the message of Islam, and passed away before embracing Islam." Here's the link.
|
Taking Islam as just a religion (which I'll cover in Part 3 of this series), building the Mosque may actually be more than unwise. It may be unconstitutional as it is being promoted by politicians and may be funded by tax-payer dollars.
Thomas J. Clement
This Week's Recommended Articles
If you don't read the newspaper, you are uninformed.
If you do read the newspaper, you are misinformed.
Mark Twain, The Innocents Abroad, 1869
Around The World And Right Here
Around The World And Right Here
What They Don't Tell You About Marriage, Kids and More by Heidi Raykeil, AOL Health
Glenn Beck's Restoring Honor Rally Changes Hearts and Minds by The Central Texas 9-12 Project
Patrick J. Michaels discusses ClimateGate on FOX's Hannity
The Higher Education Bubble: Ready to Burst? by Michael Barone, Rasmussen Reports
Bruce Campbell on the horror franchise that launched his career: All roads lead to Evil Dead, interview by Gina McIntyre, Los Angeles Times
Down Under and November: Why Australia Has Democrats Worried, by Arif Panju, Big Government
Forget Netbooks, iPad Cannibalizing Entire PC Industry by John Paczkowski, All Things Digital
Morning Bell: Half-Billion Dollar Schools Can’t Fix American Education, Heritage Foundation
Brokeand Building the Most Expensive School in U.S. History by Allysia Finley, Wall Street Journal
The Myth Of The Age Of Aquariua, by Alicia Colon, The Irish Examiner
Critics say Mexico slow in acting on lessons from Colombia's dismantling of killer cartels by: Frank Bajak And Alexandra Olson, Associated Press
The Politics of Bedbugs -- Conservatives say that the ban on DDT is to blame for the recent resurgence in bedbugs, Newsweek
Nine Years After September 11 -- United We Stood, Divided We Now Stand by Dan Gainor, NewsBusters
Wait, Pay, Cough: FDA Seeks To Limit Consumer Access to Cough Medicine by Kerri Toloczko, Big Government
Economy
Economy
The environmental movement in retreat by George F. Will, Washington Post
We Need More Skilled Workers by John Ratzenberger, Big Hollywood
(you mean it's getting worse?) DNC chairman: Dems have helped the economy 'turn a corner' by J. Taylor Rushing, The Hill
The 'Summer of Recovery' Ends, Epic Fail Fall Begins by Clarice Feldman, American Thinker
'Bankrupt' Western Governments Need 'Ruthanasia' by: Julie Crawshaw, Newsmax
The Failure of the Liberal Economic Experiment? by James K. Glassman, Commentary
JFK and Obama on tax cuts and empoyment, The Winston Group
(just in case your local paper chose not to mention this) Fidel latest to say Cuba's communism doesn't work by Paul Haven, Associated Press
Immigration, Race, and Religion
Immigration, Race, and Religion
Evangelist Preaches Against Islam Near 9/11 Site, Associated Press
Iran Woman Who Faced Stoning to Be Lashed, Son Says, Associated Press
An Arabic arm-chair quarterback remains confused: It’s clear we overreacted to 9/11, by Fareed Zakaria, Newsweek
Brigitte Bardot's shifting passions by Eric Pape, Los Angeles Times
Progessive Community? Eliseo Medina of SEIU explains how making illegals 'legal" will mint 8 million new Democrats
Learning About the 'Arab Lobby' by Peter Schweizer, Big Peace
(I agree): Top US commander: Burning Quran endangers troops, by Kimberly Dozier, Associated Press
The five racist cartoons Google wants you to see, but no one else does, Valleywag'
Diversity' Perversity: NY Schools Teaching Whitewashed Islamic History From the Regents exam grading guide: "Award 1 credit (up to a maximum of 2 credits) for each different way Islam improved the lives of people in Spain." by Andrew G. Bostom, Pajamas Media
(build a Mosque but don't burn a Koran?) Bonfire of the Insanities by Ann Coulter
Sister of 9/11 Victim Destroys Sanctimonious Ground Zero Mosque Proponent, Breitbart
No, Professor Ahmed, the Founders Were Not So Fond of Islam -- While doing the MSM circuit this week, American University professor Akbar Ahmed told some whoppers about Adams, Jefferson, and Franklin, by Laura Rubenfeld, Pajamas Media
Interfaith Tools of Shariah: Religious Coalition Denounces Rampant Islamophobia in America' by Faith J. H. McDonnell, Big Peace
If We Don’t Build It, They Will Kill You?, Claudia Rosett, Forbes
Media
Media
Soros Launches Frontal Assault Against Tea Party by Kurt Nimmo, Infowars.com
Katie Couric: Perking Up for Liberal Spin, Media Research Center
Media Scold America's "Fear," "Rage" and "Racism;" Don't Call Our "Cotton-Pickin' President" a Muslim!, Media Research Center
Bonus: Obnoxious Liberal Quotes that Couldn’t Fit in Our Labor Day Editio by Rich Noyes, NewsBusters
(in a world where all non-Muslim violence is attributed to Christians) ABC, NPR and PBS Hosts Equate Christian and Muslim Violence, by Dennis Prager
Hometown Heartbreak for NY Times: Mosque Opposition Spreads to Sophisticated New York City, by Clay Waters, NewsBusters
Ronald Reagan biopic planned -- Producers want to avoid mistakes of controversial 2003 mini by Paul Bond, Hollywood Reporter
The BBC completely fails to understand the Tea Party movement by Janet Daley, Telegraph
(they hate her so much, they make things up) 'Refudiating' the Vanity Fair Palin Piece by Katrina Trinko, National Review
(and speaking of making things up...) Make-Believe Media Paints Discovery Channel Earther-Terrorist as an Anti-Immigrant Hating Racist, by Susan Swift, Big Journalism
Turn Off Fox! Wait … what? by James Hibberd, The Live Feed
41 Obama White House aides owe the IRS $831,000 in back taxes -- and they're not alone, Andrew Malcolm, Los Angeles Times
Obama
Obama
Why Las Vegas and D.C. are similiar: Obama’s Disease Threatens Our Future by Tim Slagle, Big Government
Lukewarm Reception for Obama's R&D Tax Credit, Fox News
(the waste will disgust you) Obama's $50 Billion Union Infrastructure Boondoggle, by Michelle Malkin, Townhall
Your Tax Dollars at Work…for Obama by Fred Lucas, American Spectator
How Obama Thinks, by Dinesh D'Souza, Forbes
(prepare to spew coffee) Obama: I Am Absolutely Committed To Fiscal Responsibility, Breitbart
Healthcare Reform? Promises…Promises by Dr. Elaina George, Big Government
Mr. Obama, Your Arrogance is Unappealing by Jedediah Bila, Human Events
Economic Indicators Pose Challenge to Obama Sales Pitch, Fox News
ObamaCare 'Amnesia' -- Long ago, in a political galaxy far, far away, Democrats passed . . ., Wall Street Journal
Sebelius to Insurers: Shut Up Or Else on ObamaCare Increasing Premiums; To AP, It's Mere 'War of Words' by Tom Blumer, NewsBusters
(the buck never stops here) Obama says economic recovery 'painfully slow,' blames Republicans, Associated Press
Politics
Politics
Lefty magazine promotes teachers' guides, claims schools aren’t providing a liberal viewpoint by Chris Moody The Daily Caller
Why the Right Fears Transforming America -- and the Left Seeks It, by Dennis Prager
(playing the Hate Card?) Howard Dean: Limbaugh, Beck and Ingraham Part of 'Hate Wing of GOP' by Noel Sheppard, NewsBusters
Small Sample of Philly Voter Rolls Reveals Hundreds of Ineligible Names an ex-DOJ lawyer finds out just how damaging the DOJ failure to enforce up-to-date voter lists can be to the republic, by Nicole S. Marrone, Pajamas Media
Shake up: The Tea Partiers are coming to the staid Senate by Jonathan Strong, Daily Caller
Liberal actor James Brolin: I heart Reagan Star of 2003 miniseries 'Reagans' talks exclusively by Paul Bond, Hollywood Reporter
Palin and the Left’s Status-Anxiety by Shannon Love, Chicago Boyz
Conservatism does not equal racism. So why do many liberals assume it does? by Gerard Alexander, Washington Post
Politics
|
|
|
|